Home

2014-15 RESOLUTIONS

Elementary Policy

The Utah state government should provide a tax credit or incentive to Utah businesses that provide their employees with a public transit pass.

Jr. High/ Middle School Policy

The Utah state government should establish policies and/or programs to substantially improve Utah’s air quality.

Jr. High/ Middle School L-D

When in conflict, the state of Utah’s moral obligation to improve air quality precedes other considerations.

DEBATE provides an excellent opportunity for students to use their skills of reading, thinking, writing, speaking and listening.

Individual students or teams of two research a controversial issue to collect facts and expert opinions for/against a proposed change (stated as a resolution). They prepare cases by using these data and making inferences.

Teams face opponents in timed speeches and attempt to elicit judges’ votes by stating a strong case and refuting opponent’s claims with contradictory facts and explanations.

  • Elementary students argue either as an affirmative or a negative team.
  • Intermediate students are prepared to argue both affirmatively and negatively.
  • Participation in the debate process incorporates language arts skills, science curriculum and social studies concepts.

DEBATE SEGMENT TIME LIMITS:

Policy

Constructive Speeches – 3 minutes elementary – 5 minutes intermediate
Recess – 2 minutes
Rebuttal Speeches – 1 1/2 minutes elementary – 2 1/2 minutes intermediate

LINCOLN-DOUGLAS

(Same times for elementary and intermediate)

Affirmative Constructive – 3 minutes
Cross-examination – 1 1/2 minutes
Negative Constructive – 3 1/2 minutes
Cross-examination – 1 1/2 minutes
First Affirmative Rebuttal – 1 1/2 minutes
Negative Rebuttal – 2 minutes
Second Affirmative Rebuttal – 1 minute

*In addition to these times, each Jr. High/Middle School Debater will have two minutes to use as “prep time.”